Doug's picture
High Frequency Measurements Web Page
Douglas C. Smith

 Address:  P. O. Box 1457, Los Gatos, CA 95031
 TEL:      800-323-3956/408-356-4186
 FAX:      408-358-3799
 Mobile:   408-858-4528
 URL:      www.dsmith.org
 Email:    doug@dsmith.org



Technical Tidbit - November 2008
Switching Power Supply Noise - Magnetic Fields Revisited

View of test setup

Figure 1.
Test Setup for Measuring Magnetic Fields Generated by a Switching Power Supply


Abstract: Magnetic fields emanating from switching power supplies can cause significant problems in electronic systems. These problems are often difficult to diagnose as they can result in what appear to be intermittent problems or occasional corruption of data. A simple method of measuring magnetic fields radiating from switching power supplies is presented. The measurement method is both easier to use and the result is more intuitive than conventional ways of measuring such magnetic fields.

Discussion: Figure 1 shows the test setup with an off-the-shelf switching power supply. The work lamp contains a 12 Volt, 50 Watt lamp that acts as a load on the power supply and the square wire loop is used to measure the magnetic fields. The loop is the same one that appears in many of my Technical Tidbits and is shown in Figure 2. It is made from AWG 16 gauge stiff brass wire that is first soldered to a BNC barrel adapter on one end, then covered with heat shrink tubing, and finally the other end is pushed into the center pin receptacle of the BNC connector. Sometimes I use this loop to inject magnetic fields into equipment using high voltage pulses (electrical fast transients, EFT) making the solder connection of the wire to the BNC adapter critical for safety, but here the solder just makes the connection of the wire to the outside of the BNC adapter more reliable.


loop used for measurement

Figure 2.
Wire Loop Used for Magnetic Field Measurements


Many switching power supplies do not have a specification on allowed magnetic field emissions and this can cause a problem. Since the radiated magnetic fields are often due to parasitics, they can increase significantly due to a seemingly innocuous component or layout change. The magnetic field specifications I have seen usually specify the magnetic field itself over a specified bandwidth. Such a specification, although technically correct, does not lead to a quick understanding of the implications of the field. Ultimately, the magnetic field maybe converted to a voltage in a circuit resulting in a problem. To calculate that voltage can be a complicated, time consuming process.

An easier way to specify the magnetic field is to define the geometry of a loop (such as the one in Figure 2), a termination for the loop (50 Ohms in this case), and the allowed induced voltage in the loop over a bandwidth. This specification has immediate intuitive value. If a two cm loop pickups up hundreds of millivolts, so will other conductors in the area. To the extend other conductors define larger loops, maybe more voltage would be induced into them. A loop output into 50 Ohms of hundreds of millivolts peak or more indicates a problematic level of magnetic emissions that can affect nearby circuits, especially circuits on two layer PCBs which are common in consumer electronics.

Figure 3 shows the loop of Figure 2 positioned over the power transformer of the switching power supply in Figure 1, a likely source of magnetic field emissions. Physical layout of the PCB in a power supply and component connections can also generate magnetic field emissions as well.

pickup loop positioned over power transformer

Figure 3. Magnetic Loop Positioned Over Power Transformer of Switching Power Supply


Figure 4 shows the resulting loop output into the 50 Ohm scope input impedance (50 Ohm coax was used). The resulting peak of 400 mV is large enough to affect nearby circuits and should be reduced by either changing the design of the power transformer or using a metal cover over the power supply to short out the magnetic fields emanating from the supply. Any highly conductive metal that will allow eddy currents to cancel the field from the power supply will do.

Although there may be some electric field pickup by the unshielded loop, I estimate it to be around 50 mV or less, it is not enough to change the conclusion that this power supply can be a problem if circuits are mounted directly over the top of the supply or sensitive analog circuits are within 10 cm or maybe even further away. If one were to flip the loop over and compare waveforms, the difference in the two plots would be mostly due to electric field coupling.

scope plot from pickup loop

Figure 4.
Scope Plot of Loop Output into 50 Ohms
(Vertical scale = 100 mV/div, Horizontal scale = 50 ns/div)


I usually like to ensure that the output from a 2.5 cm, one inch, loop loaded by 50 Ohms and passed over the surface of a switching power supply is less than 50 mV peak. At that level, problems should be rare. However, if you have sensitive circuits, even a field resulting in 50 mV in the loop can be a problem. I have seen a small computer tape backup drive that was affected by a switching supply module about 15 cm away. The switching module induced 4 Volts peak into a 2 cm loop! The tape head in such drives is a sensitive receiver for fields originating in switching supplies.

Summary: Measuring magnetic field emissions from switching power supplies by measuring the voltage induced in a loop of specified dimensions is easy and gives useful results.

To see a short ~five minute video in mp4 format of the measurement in Figure 1, click on the picture below. The picture links to the mp4 file on my podcast site http://emcesd-podcast.com.
You can get the free multi-platform VLC media player at http://www.videolan.org if your media player cannot play mp4 files. The free player Quicktime from Apple can also play mp4 files. Clicking on the picture should play the video in your browser or you can right click and select to save the video as a file on your computer. If you can't play mp4 files, you can watch this video on YouTube using Flash by clicking here.

picture linking video

Figure 5. Click on this Picture to See Video Showing Measurement of Magnetic Field Emission from an Off-The-Shelf Switching Power Supply
(You can also watch this video on YouTube using Flash by clicking here)

Additional articles on this website related to this topic are:
  1. Signal and Noise Measurement Techniques Using Magnetic Field Probes (~600K)
    • (1999 IEEE EMC Symposium paper)
  2. December 2000, An Easy to Build Shielded Magnetic Loop Probe
  3. February 2001, Switching Power Supplies - Effects on Circuits, Magnetic Fields
  4. May 2008, The Square Shielded Loop - Part 1
    (Construction Details)
  5. June 2008, The Square Shielded Loop - Part 2, Parasitic Coupling
  6. July 2008, The Square Shielded Loop - Part 3, Parasitic Coupling Between Unshielded Wire Loops
  7. August 2008, The Square Shielded Loop - Part 4, Coupling to a PCB
    (From Shielded and Unshielded Magnetic Loops)
Equipment used in this Technical Tidbit:
  1. The oscilloscope used in this Technical Tidbit is an Agilent DSO5054A, a great little scope that is easy to use and boots in 9 seconds flat!
If you like the information in this article and others on this website, much more information is available in my courses. Click here to see a listing of upcoming courses on design, measurement, and troubleshooting of chips, circuits, and systems.

Click here for a description of my latest seminar titled (now available online as a WebEx seminar):

EMC Lab Techniques for Designers
(How to find EMC problems and have some confidence your system will pass EMC testing while it is still in your lab).


D-104 mike
Check out my podcast containing mp3 format short tutorials, tech news and more! Just click on the microphone to see the listing of free audio programs. Content is added every week  on technical topics so check back frequently.
Top of page
Home

Questions or suggestions? Contact me at doug@dsmith.org
Copyright © 2008 Douglas C. Smith