High Frequency Measurements Web Page
Douglas C. Smith

 page header graphic



Technical Tidbit - June 2014
Radiated Emissions Can be Strongly Affected by Setup, A Problem for Testing Standards
(An Example Using a Class D Stereo Audio Amplifier
)

Test setup with Class D amp

Figure 1.
Test Setup for Measuring Common Mode Current on the Amplifier Cables

Abstract: Radiated emissions measurements of table top equipment are usually made with the equipment placed on a non-conductive table. But such equipment is often used on conductive surfaces, like a metal desk, and can couple to the conductive surface to enhance emissions, essentially turning the conductive surface into part of an antenna structure. When this happens, standard testing of emissions can understate actual emissions. A Class D (actually labeled Class Z) stereo amplifier is used to illustrate this effect by measuring common mode current on its cables.

Class D (and newer class "Z") digital audio amplifiers are potentially a source of noise strong enough to exceed international radiated emissions limits. Figure 1 shows the test setup for a Lepai LP-2020A+ digital class Z stereo amplifier. Two 8 Ohm power resistors serve as speaker loads and are connected at the ends of the small wires exiting to the right and left. A Fischer F-33-1 current probe is placed over the power and speaker leads from the amplifier. The amplifier is sitting on a blue ESD mat covering the table.

For this test, no input source of audio was used. Behavior of the amplifier driven with an audio signal will be the subject of another Technical Tidbit.

Since the amplifier easily fits into the palm of a hand, it should not be able to drive much common mode current out all the cables in phase as the amplifier case would have to be the other half of the antenna and it is too small to act like an efficient antenna below 100 MHz. Yet in Figure 2, the common mode current on the cables would likely cause emissions that would equal or exceed Class B from 30 MHz up to a little over 100 MHz. The common mode current is plotted from 0 to 300 MHz. The level of common mode current that could cause emissions from the cables to reach the CISPR Class B limit from 30 MHz to just above 200 MHz is at 30 dBuV (left scale on the plot). The plot is at 30 dBuV or more for much of the range from about 30 MHz to about 110 MHz, a likely emissions failure.

The amplifier actually is emitting noise over a wide band but the common mode current flows for those frequencies for which the driving impedance of the cables is low, that is, one or more of the cables is near 1/4 wave resonance. In this case the speaker wires are 2 meters long and that explains the amplitude in the 30-40 MHz range.

CMI plot of Figure 1

Figure 2.
Common Mode Current from Setup in Figure 1


In Figure 3, the amplifier is raised up 9.5 cm on a paper cup over the ESD mat the amplifier had been setting on. The a top view of the setup is shown in Figure 4.

Amp raised above ESD mat

Figure 3. Amplifier Raised 9.5 cm Above ESD Mat


Top view of raised amp

Figure 4. Top View of Amplifier Raised 9.5 cm Above ESD Mat


The resultant common mode current on the cables is shown in Figure 5 and is at or below 30 dBuV across the range, quite a decrease! Apparently the amplifier chassis is coupling to the ESD mat core which is apparently conductive enough (ESD mats often have a conductive core and a high resistance outer surface) to act as the other half of the antenna for the cables, sometimes called a counterpoise. When the amplifier is raised off the mat, this coupling is decreased, and the amplifier cannot drive as much current on the cables because it must rely more on its small enclosure as the counterpoise.


Common mode current from Figure 4

Figure 5. Common Mode Current on Leads of Amplifier Raised 9.5 cm Above ESD Mat

Figures 6 and 7 show the amplifier back down on the ESD mat, but with a ferrite installed and the resulting common mode current on the wires respectively.


Ferrites added to amp on ESD mat

Figure 6. Ferrite Added to Leads From Amplifier


CM current with ferrite on amp leads

Figure 7. Common Mode Current on Leads of Amplifier on ESD Mat With Ferrite on Leads


The common mode current is below 30 dBuV now across the range, and the amplifier with its ferrite core and cables is likely to pass an emissions test, at least from cable emissions due to driving the cables in phase relative to the amplifier chassis.

The important point to be made is that emissions testing for table top gear is normally performed on a non-conductive table. Based on the performance with the amplifier raised on the cup, I suspect the emissions test may be passed. But, what if the amplifier is used on a conductive (metal) desk or placed on the metal enclosure of a cable TV set top box? The proximity of the metal will allow more current to flow on the amplifier leads, causing increased emissions. In this and similar cases, official radiated emissions testing would understate the emissions.

Summary: Class D amplifiers can make good noise sources for experiments. In this case, standard radiated emissions testing for compliance may understate emissions from some devices that couple to conductive table tops.

Technical Tidbit on this site related to this article:
Equipment used in this Technical Tidbit:

NEW: Click here, to see descriptions and registration information on my one hour webinars than can solve difficult design problems quickly. Touching on topics like signal integrity, EMC, ESD, and general analog and digital design, these webinars are a quick way to get your design working. There are public presentations every week as well as private presentations on demand for as low as $40/person. New webinars are added periodically.

Check out my public seminar offering in Boulder City, NV. This is one of the best seminar values around because the industry typical fee includes more than just the seminar and lunch. It includes airport transportation in NV, lodging in the historic Boulder City Dam Hotel and Museum, and breakfast and lunch each day. Click here for more details.

The combination of the material presented, the venue, and the passionate presentation will likely make for the best technical short course/seminar you have ever taken! Didn't think a technical presentation can be passionate,? This one is. The result is this short course/seminar will likely be the most informative, practical, and FUN seminar you can attend.

If you like the information in this article and others on this website, much more information is available in my courses. Click here to see a listing of upcoming courses on design, measurement, and troubleshooting of chips, circuits, and systems. Click here to see upcoming seminars in Boulder City, NV.

Boulder Dam Hotel and Museum
Our office, laboratory, and classrooms are located in the
----------
Historic Boulder City Dam Hotel and Museum
1305 Arizona Street, Boulder City, Nevada 89005
Phone: (702) 293-3510
----------
Come for a technical seminar, design review/troubleshooting, or just for a visit and mix a little history of the Old West with your work!


Hangar One
Our Silicon Valley associate office and lab are located at
----------
NASA-Ames Research Center
RMV Technology Group
Bldg. 19, Suite 1073, M/S 19-46C
Moffett Field, CA  94035


Is your product failing ESD, EMC, or performance testing? Attend one of my webinars. Contact me at doug@dsmith.org for more details or click here.

Need help with a design or additional training on technical subjects? Click on the image below to go to CircuitAdvisor.com, an engineering resource for training, news, and fun. The site is being reorganized for group memberships and should be back up soon.

Click here for a description of one of my seminars titled (now also available online as a WebEx seminar):

EMC Lab Techniques for Designers
(How to find EMC problems and have some confidence your system will pass EMC testing while it is still in your lab).



Top of page
Home

Questions or suggestions? Contact me at doug@dsmith.org
Copyright 2014 Douglas C. Smith